Poisoning puts business with Russia under a cloud
The Guardian
November 29, 2006
The poisoning in London of
a former KGB officer, Alexander Litvinenko, will damage investor
confidence in Russia, the primary trade association representing those
doing business between Britain and Russia warned yesterday.
The warning comes at a time of unprecedented interest in Russian
companies raising money on the London Stock Exchange, and coincides
with increased criticism by Moscow of Shell and other western firms
operating in Russia.
"While there is no proof as to who is responsible, this horrible
incident will add fuel to the negative views expressed in the western
media about the rule of law in Russia and the activities of the Russian
state," said Godfrey Cromwell, executive director of the Russo-British
Chamber of Commerce, which celebrates its 90th anniversary this year .
"Such things matter a great deal to investors looking at Russia and,
whoever was the perpetrator, this type of publicity will deter some
investors," he added.
Businessmen active in the west such as Russian emigre, Alex Konanykhin,
agree. "Foreign investors now read reports about Russia being an
authoritarian country where political opposition has been stifled and
where the legal system is controlled by the government and used for
taking over lucrative companies," said Mr Konanykhin who is a former
friend of the now-jailed Mikhail Khodorkovsky, founder of Russian oil
company Yukos.
Despite the bad publicity, Mr Konanyhkin does not think it will change the ways of the Kremlin.
The Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) this
week criticised the Russian government for its expansion into key
economic sectors in a report on the economy. It also pointed to
concerns about Gazprom the state-run energy company, and its "seemingly
insatiable appetite for asset acquisition."
But Artyom Konchin, equity analyst with Aton Capital in Moscow, is
confident that western investors will not be chased away by the latest
high-profile problems. "I have not seen any [negative] echoes yet and I
do not expect the sentiment of investors to change much. People are
very pragmatic when it comes to money," he argues.
"After all, 90% of those who invested in [the recent flotation of]
Rosneft were those who invested in Yukos [the company alleged to have
had its assets stolen by Rosneft]," he adds.
A huge swath of Russian companies - many coming from the sector such as
Rosneft - have had full shares or depository receipts listed on the
London Stock Exchange.
The electricity generator, OGK-5, is one of the latest businesses to
successfully raise money despite unease about the way western groups
such as Shell and BP are being treated in Russia.
Shell has been under attack over alleged environmental damage on its
Sakhalin-2 gas project amid attempts by Russian state-owned Gazprom, to
muscle into the scheme.
Many Russian commentators put the two events together and Mr Konchin
says there is no doubt that the Kremlin would like more control over a
sector where the value has rocketed on the back of rising energy
prices.
Mr Konanykhin believes the Kremlin is more concerned about asserting
its own political power than worrying about what foreign politicians or
investors think.
On the road from Moscow
Alex Konanykhin the former banker, says he has been hunted relentlessly
from one continent to another for over a decade by forces acting for
the Kremlin.
A beneficiary of the early 1990s move from a managed to a free
enterprise economy, Mr Konanykhin once ran a $300m finance house in
Moscow - the Russian Exchange Bank.
But in 1992 he discovered that two former KGB men had approached
individual shareholders about winning their stakes in an attempt to
launch a takeover. Within days Mr Konanykhin found himself being
kidnapped by associates of the two men while on a business trip to
Budapest with his wife.
"You will sign your companies and bank accounts over to us," the men
demanded. When he asked what would happen if he did not, they replied:
"Then you might accidentally drown in your apartment's bath."
Mr Konanykhin and his wife Elena managed to flee, first to Slovakia and
then to America but soon found many of their assets in Russia frozen
and their reputations shredded by the KGB.
By 1994, one of the banker's former kidnappers was boasting in a
Russian business newspaper that he wouldn't bet a dollar on Mr
Konanykhin's life.
The Russian businessman, who was granted political asylum in the US and
now runs an internet business there, says his attempts to win justice
in his home country and question the ethics of the state that allowed
this to happen just got him deeper into conflict. The FBI warned him in
1995 to take care as they had information that the KGB had hired US
mafia men to get rid of him.
The Russian government tried three times to get him extradited with the
help of US officials but he managed to fight them off with court
judgments that deemed the attempts unlawful.
Mr Konanykhin, who has taken up martial arts with a vengeance, says he
keeps fear at bay with "mental training". And while he no longer
expects to meet a violent death, he says he will not be having children
with the wife he loves.
"Children represent a perfect pressure point. A man might stop caring
about himself but will have difficulty in stopping caring about people
he loves."
|
|